How to Pick the Right Pin Back for Your Enamel Pins

When you’re ordering enamel pins, the design usually steals the spotlight. But here’s a truth we’ve learned from thousands of customers: your pin back makes all the difference. The right back keeps your pin secure, comfortable, and practical for how you’ll actually use it. At Dream Maker Pins, every pin comes with a black rubber back by default, and you can always upgrade to locking backs or request butterfly clasps if that’s what works best for you. Let’s break it all down. Browse our designs here: Dream Maker Pins — Enamel Pins.

Why We Chose Rubber Pin Backs

We ship every pin with a black rubber clutch back. Why? Because most of our customers wear their pins on hats, jackets, or bags, and rubber backs hold snugly without catching hair or scratching skin. Over the years, we’ve heard a consistent message:

• Rubber backs are more comfortable than metal clasps.
• They don’t get tangled in hair (a common complaint with butterfly clasps).
• They’re easy to replace and keep extras on hand.

That’s why we made rubber backs our standard—it’s the best mix of comfort and security for everyday wear.

Locking Pin Backs: The Upgrade for Collectors

For pins that are sentimental, limited edition, or likely to be worn during active use, we always recommend upgrading to locking pin backs. These little mechanisms keep your pin locked in place until you release it. No more lost pins at concerts, runs, or while traveling.

If you want maximum security, especially for keepsake or high-value pins, locking backs are the way to go.

We carry the easy, tool-free style—sometimes called “pinch & pull”—for reliable hold without the mini Allen wrench.

• Stays put: Ideal for travel, events, uniforms, and active days.
• Tool-free: Squeeze to release (details in the FAQ below).

Butterfly Clasps: Available on Request

While butterfly clasps aren’t our standard anymore, we absolutely understand why some people still prefer them. In fact, we’ve heard from several customers with disabilities who find butterfly clasps easier to grip and handle. Accessibility matters, and we’re more than happy to swap rubber backs for butterfly clasps if requested.

Just drop us a note with your order—we’ll make sure you get the backs that work best for you.

Which Pin Back Should You Choose?

• Rubber Backs (default): Best for hats, jackets, and everyday wear. Comfortable, safe, and won’t tangle in hair.
• Locking Backs (upgrade): Best for collectors, travelers, or anyone who can’t risk losing a special pin.
• Butterfly Clasps (on request): Best for those who need an easy-grip option or prefer the traditional pinback feel.

Choosing the right pin back isn’t just about keeping your pin in place—it’s about making sure it fits your lifestyle. That’s why we give you options. Whether you want the comfort of rubber, the security of locking backs, or the accessibility of butterfly clasps, Dream Maker Pins has you covered. Because the perfect pin deserves the perfect hold.